Who Gives A Crap vs. Cloud Paper: Best Sustainable Bamboo Toilet Paper for USA Shoppers?

Introduction

In an era of increasing environmental consciousness, consumers are actively seeking sustainable alternatives for everyday products. Toilet paper, a household staple, has come under scrutiny due to its traditional reliance on virgin tree pulp. Bamboo toilet paper has emerged as a frontrunner in the sustainable paper products market, offering a rapidly renewable resource that can significantly reduce deforestation. For USA shoppers looking to make an eco-friendlier choice, two prominent brands frequently enter the conversation: Who Gives A Crap and Cloud Paper. This detailed analysis aims to dissect their offerings, environmental commitments, and overall value to help you make an informed decision.

Comparison Table: Who Gives A Crap vs. Cloud Paper (Bamboo TP)

Note: Specific sheet counts and pricing can vary based on product updates, promotions, and subscription tiers. Information presented is generalized for comparison purposes.

Who Gives A Crap (100% Bamboo TP) Overview

Originating from Australia with a strong social mission, Who Gives A Crap (WGAC) has established itself as a global leader in sustainable paper products. Their 100% bamboo toilet paper is a cornerstone of their offering, designed not just for eco-friendliness but also for making a tangible social impact. The brand is renowned for its commitment to donating 50% of its profits to improve sanitation and hygiene in developing countries, addressing a critical global issue.
Related: Review: The Super Absorbent Reusable Swedish Dishcloths Replacing Paper Towels in USA Homes.

WGAC’s bamboo toilet paper is 3-ply, aiming to provide a robust and absorbent experience. Each roll is individually wrapped in colorful, recyclable paper, a design choice that is both aesthetically pleasing and practical for hygiene. The company prides itself on being plastic-free, using no chlorine bleach, fragrances, or dyes in its production process. As a certified B Corporation, WGAC demonstrates high standards of social and environmental performance, accountability, and transparency.
Related: The Hydrating Solid Shampoo Bar Review: Is This Plastic-Free Haircare Essential Right for USA Lifestyles?

Cloud Paper (100% Bamboo TP) Overview

Cloud Paper is a USA-based company founded with a clear vision: to save trees by providing high-quality, sustainable paper products made entirely from bamboo. Their focus is squarely on environmental sustainability, specifically emphasizing carbon neutrality and reducing the ecological footprint associated with traditional paper production.
Related: The Zero-Waste Dish Soap Block Review: Finally, Sparkling Dishes Without Plastic in USA Kitchens.

Cloud Paper’s 100% bamboo toilet paper is 2-ply, but it frequently receives commendation for its unexpected softness and strength. Like WGAC, Cloud Paper ensures its products are free from chlorine bleach, fragrances, dyes, and BPA, catering to health-conscious consumers. All packaging is plastic-free, utilizing recycled cardboard boxes and individual paper wrappers for rolls. The company is FSC certified for responsible forestry and actively works to offset its carbon emissions, holding a Carbon Neutral certification.
Related: Is the Stainless Steel Safety Razor the Ultimate Eco-Friendly Shave for USA Men & Women?

Feature Comparison: A Deeper Dive

Material and Sustainability

Both brands utilize 100% FSC-certified bamboo, affirming their commitment to sourcing from sustainably managed forests. Bamboo is an excellent sustainable resource as it grows rapidly, requires minimal water and no pesticides, and regenerates quickly after harvesting. By choosing either brand, consumers are actively participating in reducing demand for virgin tree pulp, thus protecting forests.
Related: Are Compostable Kitchen Trash Bags Truly Strong Enough? An Eco-Living Review for USA Households.

Ply Count and User Experience

Here lies a noticeable difference: WGAC offers a 3-ply product, while Cloud Paper is 2-ply. Generally, 3-ply toilet paper is perceived as thicker and potentially more durable. WGAC users often report a sturdy and effective clean. Cloud Paper, despite being 2-ply, is frequently praised for its softness and tensile strength, surprising many who are accustomed to thicker traditional options. The preference here is highly subjective; some may prefer the robust feel of 3-ply, while others appreciate the soft yet strong nature of Cloud Paper’s 2-ply.

Packaging and Aesthetics

Both companies excel in plastic-free packaging, a crucial aspect of their environmental commitment. WGAC is famous for its bright, individually wrapped rolls, which can add a pop of color to a bathroom and ensure hygiene for each roll. Cloud Paper also uses individual paper wrappers and recycled cardboard boxes, maintaining an equally eco-conscious packaging approach, albeit with a typically more minimalist aesthetic.

Environmental and Social Impact

This is where the brands differentiate their core missions. WGAC stands out with its explicit social impact model, dedicating 50% of its profits to sanitation projects. This direct contribution appeals strongly to consumers looking for a product that gives back beyond environmental sustainability. Cloud Paper’s primary focus is on environmental impact, particularly through being carbon neutral and strictly tree-free. While both contribute positively to the planet, WGAC adds a significant humanitarian layer to its mission. Cloud Paper, by its very existence, also serves a social good by promoting sustainable consumption.

Pricing and Value

As premium bamboo toilet paper brands, both Who Gives A Crap and Cloud Paper typically command a higher price point than conventional toilet paper. However, when considering the environmental benefits, quality, and often the sheet count per roll, they can offer comparable long-term value. Both brands primarily operate on a direct-to-consumer subscription model, which usually provides the best per-roll pricing and convenience for USA shoppers. Bulk purchases from either brand generally yield better value.

Pros and Cons for Both

Who Gives A Crap (100% Bamboo TP)

Pros:

• Strong social mission: 50% of profits go to sanitation projects.
• Certified B Corporation, demonstrating high ethical and environmental standards.
• 100% FSC-certified bamboo and completely plastic-free.
• 3-ply construction offers a sturdy and absorbent feel.
• No chlorine bleach, fragrances, or dyes.
• Colorful, individually wrapped rolls are visually appealing and hygienic.
• Good sheet count per roll.

Cons:

• Can be perceived as slightly less soft by those accustomed to very plush traditional TP.
• Higher initial cost due to bulk purchase requirements for best value.
• Individual paper wrappers, while eco-friendly, create slightly more “waste” per roll to unwrap.

Cloud Paper (100% Bamboo TP)

Pros:

• USA-based company.
• 100% FSC-certified bamboo and completely plastic-free.
• Carbon Neutral certified, with a strong focus on reducing carbon footprint.
• Often praised for softness and strength, despite being 2-ply.
• No chlorine bleach, fragrances, dyes, or BPA.
• Simple, clean aesthetic in packaging.

Cons:

• While environmentally focused, does not have as direct or explicit a social welfare mission as WGAC.
• 2-ply construction might not appeal to everyone who prefers a thicker toilet paper.
• Pricing can be similar to WGAC, meaning it’s still a premium product.

Which One Is Better For Whom?

• Choose Who Gives A Crap if: You are deeply motivated by a brand’s social responsibility and want your purchase to directly contribute to humanitarian aid (sanitation projects). You appreciate a sturdy, 3-ply toilet paper and enjoy colorful, distinct packaging. Being a Certified B Corp is important to you as a mark of overall ethical business practice.
• Choose Cloud Paper if: You prioritize a USA-based company with a primary focus on environmental impact, specifically carbon neutrality. You value a toilet paper that is soft yet strong, even in a 2-ply format. A straightforward, tree-free product with minimalist branding appeals to your sensibilities.

Final Verdict

Both Who Gives A Crap and Cloud Paper represent excellent choices for USA shoppers seeking sustainable bamboo toilet paper. Their commitment to plastic-free packaging, absence of harsh chemicals, and reliance on FSC-certified bamboo makes them significantly superior to conventional options from an environmental standpoint.

The “better” choice ultimately hinges on your specific priorities. If a strong social mission and a robust 3-ply feel are paramount, Who Gives A Crap is likely your ideal match. If supporting a USA-based company, prioritizing carbon neutrality, and experiencing a soft yet durable 2-ply product are your key drivers, then Cloud Paper will serve you well.

Regardless of your selection, opting for either Who Gives A Crap or Cloud Paper signifies a conscious step towards a more sustainable lifestyle, contributing to the health of our planet, and in WGAC’s case, directly to global public health.

1. Beyond bamboo, what specific sustainability practices make Who Gives A Crap and Cloud Paper stand out for USA consumers?

Both Who Gives A Crap (WGAC) and Cloud Paper are committed to sustainability, but they highlight different aspects. WGAC uses 100% recycled paper or bamboo, is FSC certified, and often uses plastic-free packaging, delivering in recycled cardboard boxes. They also address water sanitation by donating 50% of their profits. Cloud Paper exclusively uses 100% bamboo, which is fast-growing and requires less water than traditional trees. They are also committed to plastic-free packaging and are often certified carbon-neutral, focusing on minimizing their carbon footprint throughout their supply chain. For USA shoppers, both offer a significant upgrade in environmental responsibility compared to virgin-pulp toilet paper.

2. When comparing Who Gives A Crap and Cloud Paper, which brand offers better overall value for money for USA shoppers, considering price, sheet count, and subscription options?

Determining “better value” often depends on current promotions and specific bundle sizes. Generally, both brands offer competitive pricing when purchased through their subscription services, which typically include free shipping within the USA. Who Gives A Crap often sells in larger bulk boxes (e.g., 48 rolls) which can drive down the per-roll cost, and they frequently offer discounts for first-time subscribers. Cloud Paper also provides subscription discounts and various bundle sizes. USA shoppers should compare the effective cost per sheet, as roll sizes and ply count can vary slightly between brands, and factor in whether the commitment to WGAC’s larger box size or Cloud Paper’s more frequent smaller deliveries aligns with their storage and consumption needs.

3. How do the actual toilet paper products from Who Gives A Crap and Cloud Paper compare in terms of softness, durability, and ply for everyday use in the USA?

Both brands aim for a balance of softness and strength, though user experiences can vary. Who Gives A Crap offers both a 3-ply “Premium” bamboo toilet paper and a 3-ply recycled option, known for being soft yet durable, designed to minimize tearing. Their “Dream Cloths” bamboo paper towels are also popular. Cloud Paper focuses solely on a 2-ply bamboo toilet paper, which many users describe as surprisingly soft and strong despite being two-ply, with good absorbency. For USA consumers prioritizing a very plush feel, WGAC’s 3-ply bamboo might have a slight edge, while Cloud Paper’s 2-ply is highly regarded for its balance of softness and sustainability, often feeling comparable to or better than standard virgin-pulp 2-ply options.

4. Apart from product quality, what are the key differences in their social impact initiatives or delivery logistics that USA buyers should consider when choosing between Who Gives A Crap and Cloud Paper?

A significant differentiator for Who Gives A Crap is their commitment to donating 50% of their profits to help build toilets and improve sanitation in developing countries, making a direct social impact beyond their product. They also focus on transparency in their supply chain. Cloud Paper, while environmentally focused with its bamboo sourcing and carbon neutrality, primarily emphasizes its direct environmental impact through reforestation efforts for every purchase. In terms of delivery logistics for USA buyers, both offer reliable direct-to-consumer shipping with subscription flexibility. WGAC’s larger box sizes mean less frequent deliveries, while Cloud Paper might offer more flexible recurring shipment intervals. Both prioritize plastic-free and often carbon-neutral shipping.

Related Products

• Stasher Bags vs. Bee’s Wrap: Which Reusable Food Storage Is Better for US Families’ Lunches?
• Grove Co. Concentrates vs. Branch Basics: The Ultimate Non-Toxic All-Purpose Cleaner Showdown for US Households.
• Ethique Dish Soap Bar vs. Blueland Dish Soap Tablets: Best Zero-Waste Dishwashing for Your US Kitchen?
• Is the Stainless Steel Safety Razor the Ultimate Eco-Friendly Shave for USA Men & Women?
• Review: The Super Absorbent Reusable Swedish Dishcloths Replacing Paper Towels in USA Homes.